The summer of 2017 has been filled with severe weather storms across Minnesota. Thousands of homes have been affected by hail and wind damage. For those with homeowners insurance policies, one of the most common issues is whether the policy provides coverage for "matching" the existing material (like siding, roofing, windows, etc.) when repairing the storm damage. For example, whether an insurance company can replace broken pieces of white siding with yellow siding.

In 2014, RSJ handled a case before the Minnesota Supreme Court on this very issue in Cedar Bluff v. American Family. See full case here. The Cedar Bluff case involved a Homeowners Association that could not obtain reasonably matching material to replace storm-damaged siding. The only product available for repair was one shade lighter or one shade darker. An appraisal panel determined that was not a reasonable match to the existing siding and the Association was therefore entitled to full replacement of all siding to restore the property to its uniform appearance. The Minnesota Supreme Court agreed, and held that the mismatch between storm-damaged building components and existing building components constitutes "direct physical loss or damage" that is covered by the policy.

Whether there is coverage for matching is policy specific, but virtually all policies issued in Minnesota have the same "like kind and quality," "comparable material," or "similar material" requirements that provides for material matching. In the event your insurance company denies coverage to replace storm-damage materials with matching products, you should request a copy of your policy from your agent and set an appointment with us to review your options.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Put Our Experience To Work For You

Do You Need Skilled Legal Counsel On Your Side?

When you put your trust in us, we will put our integrity and tenacity into your case. Call us at 866-291-7528, or email us to tell us about your legal needs.

We offer a free, 30-minute initial consultation.

Contact Smith Jadin Johnson »

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Locations

From The Rockies To Lake Michigan, We’ve Got You Covered

Bloomington Office
7900 Xerxes Ave South
Suite 2020
Bloomington, MN 55431

Toll Free: 866-291-7528
Fax: 612-235-7927
Map & Directions

Denver Office
1775 Sherman Street
Suite 2750
Denver, CO 80203

Toll Free: 866-291-7528
Map & Directions

Office Locations